The implantable cardioverter-defibrillator: Implications for the recognition of civil disability and proposal for medical-legal update
Abstract
Background. Indications to the implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) have been expanded in the last decade, including patients suffering from heart disease with or without functional disorders. Accordingly, the increasing number of patients with ICD is posing relevant legal implications. Currently, the Medical Committee that evaluates the legal criteria for disability is employing guidelines referring only to pacemaker devices and not to ICD. The aim of this study was to propose new indications for patients with ICD to replace the current criteria. Methods. The study included 219 patients (83%male, mean age 63 years) with ICD who were administered an anonymous questionnaire to evaluate the presence of any disability. Most patients were suffering from ischemic or non-ischemic dilated heart disease (41% and 34%, respectively). Single- and dual-chamber ICD (72%) were more frequently implanted compared to biventricular ICD (28%). Results. A higher percentage of disability was found in older patients (69±14 years) with ischemic heart disease (61%) and single- or dual-chamber ICD before ICD implantation. Conversely, a lower percentage of disability was found in younger patients (53±15 years), active workers (44%), without ischemic or non-ischemic dilated heart disease (36%), and with a lower number of biventricular ICD (22%) after ICD implantation. Conclusions. Overall, these data show that disability is currently recognized because of the presence of ICD rather than the underlying heart disease. We propose, therefore, new criteria that include the impact of the underlying heart disease for a better evaluation of disability in patients with ICD.
Anno di pubblicazione
2011
ISSN
1827-6806
ISBN
Non Disponibile
Numero di citazioni Wos
Nessuna citazione
Ultimo Aggiornamento Citazioni
Non Disponibile
Numero di citazioni Scopus
Non Disponibile
Ultimo Aggiornamento Citazioni
Non Disponibile
Settori ERC
Non Disponibile
Codici ASJC
Non Disponibile
Condividi questo sito sui social